Does Diamond’s New Fine Baking Salt Actually Yield Better Cookies?

We tested it against standard table salt; here’s how our test batch of chocolate chip cookies compared.

November 16, 2023

Photo by: Rod Komis

Rod Komis

Diamond Crystal Salt Co.’s new Fine Kosher Baking Salt promises to be a game-changer for home bakers — a specialty ingredient that supposedly enhances the breads, cakes, cookies, pastries and other baked goods we whip up in our kitchens.

“The new salt’s finer-cut crystals dissolve, mix and blend faster and more evenly than table salt into batters and doughs, producing more satisfying results for at-home chefs,” the brand says.

The salt was developed using a special refinement process that somehow uses heat and water to change the shape of the natural salt crystal, which is supposed to provide a “quick burst of flavor” that stays consistent throughout. The finer crystals also promise to be easier to blend, and be lower in sodium by volume compared to regular granulated salt.

“We believe our new Diamond Crystal Salt Co. Fine Kosher Baking Salt is the very best salt for baking,” Sonya Roberts, president of Cargill’s salt business, says in a press release. “The salt’s finer-cut crystals will enable home chefs to up their game when it comes to making the breads, cakes and cookies they love to share with family when celebrating this holiday season – or anytime of the year.”

Photo by: Amy Reiter

Amy Reiter

I decided to put the new salt to the test by baking up two batches of chocolate-chip cookies using this fabulous recipe from Food Network Kitchen, one with Diamond Crystal Salt Co. Fine Kosher Baking Salt and one with standard table salt.

So how did the new salt compare? For starters, the Fine Kosher Baking Salt looks almost like a powder. In fact, its packaging is pretty much identical to the containers I’m used to getting our baking powder in. It’s a little more granulated than baking powder, and also seemed prone to compression and clumping, requiring a little effort to break it up into its desired powdery state before measuring it out.

Photo by: Amy Reiter

Amy Reiter

It blended up as easily as promised, dissolving into the dough like a dream. The cookie dough I made with the standard table salt seemed pretty light and fluffy — but the one I made with the Fine Kosher Baking Salt was even more so, and definitely smoother and less granular.

And the final result? I made the batch with standard table salt first, and it was difficult to imagine anything that could beat the chewy perfection of those cookies. The original batch struck me as having the perfect ratio of sweet to salt, and I was worried that the batch made with the new Fine Kosher Baking Salt would be too salty.

However, turns out, the test batch cookies didn’t seem saltier at all. That balance was still there. What they did seem was lighter, crisper and somehow more delicate. The finer salt turned a standard chocolate-chip cookie into something subtly smoother, a bit more refined.

Photo by: Amy Reiter

Amy Reiter

There are probably those who would prefer the rough-hewn bendy bite of the chocolate-chip cookies made with the standard table salt. In the end, I thought both batches were delicious, but the crisp lightness of the batch made with the Fine Kosher Baking Salt kept us reaching for another cookie … and another … another.

Verdict: While I might not use the new Fine Kosher Baking Salt in every home baking project, I’ll definitely hang onto this specialty ingredient, which is available in stores nationwide and on Amazon, to try in other recipes this holiday season. It’s a keeper.

Related Content:

Next Up

Hefty’s New Snack Scarf Helps You Sneak Food Out of Parties

It features secret slider storage bag pockets to keep your leftovers fresh while keeping you warm.

This Twist on Panettone Sold Out In 8 Hours – But Now It’s Back

Get your hands on Kitsby’s vibrant ube panettone and bring something unique to the holiday party.

Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup Dumplings Might Be the Most Mind-Blowing Dish on Your Holiday Table

Kraft and chef Shirley Chung are seamlessly bringing together three comfort foods into one bite.

Miller High Life Is Selling a Leg Lamp That Dispenses Beer

It’s inspired by the one in A Christmas Story.

Franzia’s Holiday Collection Includes a Boxed-Wine Inflatable Lawn Decoration

And a coordinating 'colorful holiday ugly sweater' and wine box.

Aldi’s 2023 Advent Calendars Are Now in Stores

This year, you can count down the days in cider, sparkling wine, Irish cream and red wine either sweet or dry.

There’s Only One Holiday Drink Starbucks Serves All Over the Globe – Can You Guess Which One?

The coffee chain released a list of 27 festive beverages it serves around the world.

Starbucks Rings in the Holiday Season With a New Sugar Cookie Latte

We’re surprised it wasn’t already in the seasonal rotation.

The Secrets to Making Perfect Macarons at Home, According to a Pastry Chef

The key to success is mastering the nuances of your own kitchen.

How to Freeze Cookies and Cookie Dough

Plus precisely how to thaw and bake them.